Amnesty International and Harm Reduction International, welcome the opportunity to to contribute to the Expert Panel's work on building clear, specific and actionable recommendations aimed at enhancing the implementation of the three drug control conventions, other international instruments and all international drug policy commitments, to inform the review of the international drug policy commitments in 2029. Amnesty International and Harm Reduction International, two organizations campaigning for the full abolition of the death penalty, have been joining efforts to highlight the unlawful and arbitrary use of this cruel punishment specifically for drug-related offences for years, including before the UN Commission on Narcotic Drugs (CND).
Introduction
Research carried out independently and separately by our organizations indicates that drug-related executions have been increasing in recent years, representing more than 40% of the total number of executions recorded worldwide. Drug control has been a significant driver of the use of this punishment globally; and in several countries.
Although the use of the death penalty for drug-related offences has long been unlawful under international human rights law and standards, several governments have justified its retention in the name of drug control.
Our organizations submit to the Expert Panel established pursuant to CND resolution 68/6 (Expert Panel) that the UN Drug Conventions do not give state parties a mandate to punish drug-related crime by death, while at the same time international human rights law and standards explicitly prohibit it. As most states that still retain this punishment for drug-related offences introduced it after the adoption of the Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs of 1961, the Expert Panel should recommend UN bodies overseeing the implementation of the UN Drug Conventions to take prompt action to support its immediate abolition.
Death penalty and Drug control conventions
The UN Drug Conventions do not make any reference to the death penalty, while providing guidance on penalties applicable under the treaties. The drafting of the Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs of 1961 began in 1948 as an effort to consolidate and harmonize various multilateral treaties existing at the time.4 With regard to penalties, Article 36 of the 1961 Single Convention requests state parties to ensure that “serious offences shall be liable to adequate punishment particularly by imprisonment or other penalties of deprivation of liberty.”
The official Commentary on the Convention acknowledges the challenges during the drafting process with formulating a general international rule for offences and punishments to be implemented at national level; and the “divergent positions of different countries on matters of penal law to an even greater extent than the provisions of the earlier treaty. Its terms are therefore broader and more flexible, and their binding character even weaker.” However, the Commentary clarifies that the Plenipotentiary Conference did not accept a proposal to refer to “severe” punishment by the required two-thirds majority. The resulting Paragraph 1 retained “‘adequate’ punishment of the offences which it covers if they are serious. It further clarifies that the opponents of the word “severe” note[d] “severe” carried overtones of “retribution”, which was one of the purposes of penal law which should not be emphasized”.
In addition to restricting the notion of “adequate punishment” only to deprivation of liberty, amendments to this Article brought through the 1972 Protocol Amending the Single Convention added paragraph (b) to allow for the provision of “an alternative to conviction or punishment or in addition to conviction or punishment, that such abusers shall undergo measures of treatment, education, after-care, rehabilitation and social reintegration in conformity with paragraph 1 of article 38.” The intended aim of the foreseen penalties under the 1961 Single Convention was therefore clarified to emphasize the role of alternatives to incarceration and promote proportionate responses, rather than increasing the punitive nature of the UN drug control framework.
Similarly, the UN Convention on Psychotropic Substances of 1971 refers in its Article 22 to “adequate punishment, particularly by imprisonment or other penalty of deprivation of liberty”. It also encourages the resort to “alternative to conviction or punishment or in addition to punishment, that such abusers undergo measures of treatment, education, after-care, rehabilitation and social reintegration”. Its Commentary reiterates the limitations to punitive regimes posed by this Article, as “‘Adequate’ penalties are required only for serious offences”. While the Commentary introduces more explicitly a link between punishment and deterrent effect, it reaffirms the interpretation of adequate punishment as relating to imprisonment or another form of deprivation of liberty only. In relation to subparagraph (b), the Commentary not only clarifies that alternative measures could be applied to any offence, “no matter how serious”, but it further explains that in cases of substitute measures state parties “are bound to prosecute, although under subparagraph (b) not required to convict or punish”.
A new range of criminal offences and a more pronounced emphasis on punishment were introduced in the UN Convention against Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances of 1988. Article 3.4 (a) emphasizes the need to take into account “the grave nature” of the offences and expands the recommended punishment to include “pecuniary sanctions and confiscation.” It further limits the possibility of alternative measures to “appropriate cases of a minor nature” (Article 3.4 (c)). Importantly, greater deference is given to national frameworks, with an explicit statement that “Nothing contained in this article shall affect the principle that […] such offences shall be prosecuted and punished in conformity with that law [of the state party]” (Article 3.11).
Its Commentary underscores this turn, with priority given in the structure of paragraph 4 to heavier penalties and the need for sanctions to reflect the “grave nature” of the offences. However, it is important to note that this treaty still does not include the death penalty among the listed sanctions, nor removes reference to imprisonment as the referred punishment in the treaty.
Critically, the UN Drug Convention framework was adopted at a time when international human rights law had already developed to significantly restrict the scope of the death penalty, while envisaging its abolition as programmatic goal, as outlined in the next section. Even when considered in isolation from other developing international norms, the enhanced turn in favour of punishment does not make reference, nor can be interpreted as supporting, the death penalty. Additionally, the punitive approach historically at the core of the drug control framework has received increasing scrutiny, due to its negative health and rights implications, and discussions are intensifying regarding the need for alternative approaches.
The Most serious crime threshold
Although international human rights law allows the death penalty under certain circumstances, from the outset it clearly established the death penalty as an exceptional measure with a requirement to restrict its use to the “most serious crimes” and setting abolition as goal for retentionist countries.
The drafting of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), adopted in 1966, began in 1947. As positions differed with regard to abolition, the restriction to the “most serious crimes” was included in the very first draft of Article 6 of the Covenant, even though it attracted criticism for lacking precision. In 1982, the UN Human Rights Committee, the body monitoring ICCPR implementation, stated in its first General Comment on the right to life that “most serious crimes’ must be read restrictively to mean that the death penalty should be a quite exceptional measure.”
Two years later, the UN Economic and Social Council – of which the CND is a subsidiary body – adopted, and the UN General Assembly endorsed, without a vote the UN Safeguards Guaranteeing Protection of the Rights of Those Facing the Death Penalty. Safeguard no.1 clarifies that “In countries which have not abolished the death penalty, capital punishment may be imposed only for the most serious crimes, it being understood that their scope should not go beyond intentional crimes with lethal or other extremely grave consequences.”
Since then, the Human Rights Committee has consistently clarified that “‘The most serious crimes’ must be read restrictively and appertain only to crimes of extreme gravity, involving intentional killing. Crimes not resulting directly and intentionally in death, such as […] drug and sexual offences, although serious in nature, can never serve as the basis, within the framework of article 6, for the imposition of the death penalty. […].” Other UN bodies and mandates, including International Narcotics Control Board, have supported this interpretation.
The prohibition of the imposition of the death penalty for drug-related offences constitutes a fundamental safeguard to protect the right to life under international human rights law and standards.
State Practice
As the UN drug and human rights treaties were being developed, including to restrict the use of the death penalty, authorities in several countries moved in the opposite direction. Analysis of legislative developments in UN member states that currently retain the death penalty for drug-related offences in law shows that only three countries – China, Egypt and Iran –22 are known to have had this punishment in place when the 1961 Single Convention was adopted.
Available information indicates that the majority of UN member states introduced the death penalty for these offences in the following three decades, with 8 countries doing so in the 1970s, 14 in the 1980s and 4 in the 1990s (see tables in Annex), setting their legislation against the spirit and text recommendations of the international treaties that the international community had been adopting.
Conclusions and recommendations
The above analysis shows that use of the death penalty in the name of drug control has no support in either the UN drug or human rights treaties.
Recent efforts by international drug control mechanisms to address this human rights violation have not gone far enough, nor led to an end of executions for drug-related crimes. The use of the death penalty for drug-related offences remains a contentious issue at the CND, which has precluded this body from taking a formal position on this important matter. While UNODC representatives have on occasions recalled the UN’s unconditional opposition to the death penalty, advocacy and advances towards abolition have not been included in programmatic documents. These bodies must unequivocally and publicly condemn use of the death penalty for drug-related offences and challenge the ill-founded perceptions that the death penalty can serve as an effective drug control tool.
Amnesty International and Harm Reduction International recommend the Expert Panel to condemn the use of the death penalty for drug-related offences as contravening the spirit of and punishments envisaged under the UN Drug Conventions; and to call on international drug control mechanisms, including the CND and UNODC, to ensure the implementation of the UN Drug Conventions is consistent with international human rights obligations, including in relation to the death penalty.
In particular, the Expert Panel should call on:
- CND to establish a standing agenda item to address the human rights impacts of drug policies, including in relation to the death penalty;
- UNODC to ensure that human rights are a central part of its monitoring work, to incorporate an explicit commitment to promote death penalty abolition (both generally and for drug-related offences specifically) in its forthcoming strategy; and to ensure that its cooperation with countries that still retain the death penalty does not risk contributing to the use of the death penalty or other human rights violations, in line with UN policy;27
- all states that retain the death penalty to fully abolish it as a matter of urgency.
Don't miss our events and publications
Subscribe to our newsletter